
Every Simulator Has a Cost Model
Paper platforms differ in what they charge a simulated order. Some apply realistic commission schedules, some apply none, and many apply an implicit cost of zero by filling at a single midpoint price. Zero is still a cost model — just an unrealistic one.
Before journaling on any platform, find its fill and cost documentation. What price does it use for market orders? Does it model spread, commission, borrow fees, or delay? Whatever the answer, it belongs in the journal header for every session.
Commission, Spread, and Delay Assumptions
When the platform does not model a cost, enter your own assumption in the 'Assumed fees and spread' field. A flat synthetic commission per order, an observed or conservative spread, and a stated execution delay turn an abstract fill into a more defensible hypothetical.
- Assumed commission per simulated order (flat or per unit).
- Assumed or observed spread at order time.
- Modeled or assumed execution delay.
- Whether partial fills were possible in the model.
Writing Down What the Model Omits
The most dangerous field in any simulation is the one that does not exist: no market impact for size, no queue priority, no gap risk between sessions, no rejection of stale quotes. These omissions are not bugs — they are the simplifications that make a teaching platform usable.
Journals stay honest by listing the omissions as 'interpretation limits.' An entry that says 'model cannot show queue depth or impact' is more rigorous than a live-looking fill with no caveats.
Stress-Testing Your Own Assumptions
A useful review exercise: take one completed Review Sheet and rerun the arithmetic with worse assumptions — double the spread, add a delay, cut the fill to half quantity. If the lesson of the entry survives harsher assumptions, it was robust. If it depended on the friendly defaults, the entry was reading the model, not the market.
Log both runs. The spread between the friendly and the stressed version measures how much of your 'result' was borrowed from the simulator's generosity.
Cost & Assumption Ledger
| Cost Type | Simulator Default | Assumption to Write | Field |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commission | Usually zero | Per-side fee you assume | Fees assumed: 0.05% |
| Spread | Often none or fixed | Quoted gap per entry | Spread: 0.1% assumed |
| Slippage | Zero or ignored | Deviation from quoted price | Slip: 1 tick assumed |
| Latency | Instant fills | Delay between intent and fill | Latency: 1 tick assumed |
| Margin/limits | Unlimited virtual capital | Real constraint you simulate | Constraint: none modeled |
Journal Checklist
- Are all cost assumptions written as fields, not defaults?
- Is the simulator's cost model (none, fixed, modeled) named in the header?
- Are assumed fees/spread applied consistently across entries?
- Is 'cost not modeled' recorded where the sim provides nothing?
- Does the entry separate gross result from net-of-assumptions result?
Review Note
Treat every simulator default as an assumption you chose, not a fact you observed. Chosen assumptions can be reviewed; invisible ones cannot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Because 'free' fills teach wrong economics. An assumed-cost field shows whether the idea survives real-world friction — even if the number is an assumption.
Whatever your platform omits silently — usually spread and slippage. Name the omission and write an assumption; that's more honest than the default zero.
Consistent beats precise. A documented 0.1% assumption used everywhere is reviewable; a 'roughly right' memory is not.
Continue Exploring
Separating Practice from Performance Claims
Why simulated results can never be presented as evidence of future returns — and what an educational journal may legitimately claim.
Paper Fills Are Not Live Fills
Why a simulated execution differs from a real market fill, and how to record the gap honestly in an educational trade journal.
Recording the Order Idea Before the Outcome
How to fix your assumptions in writing before running a simulated order, so the review compares your real plan — not your memory of it.