Independent guides to hypothetical trade records, simulated fills, order assumptions, and reflective review using paper-trading examples.
Every entry in the Reviewbook moves through the same three stages. The discipline is in the sequence — no simulated order exists before its written plan, and no plan is finished until it has been reviewed.
Write the order idea before any simulated outcome exists: the hypothetical instrument, the intended action, the one-sentence rationale, and the condition that would prove the idea wrong.
Log the hypothetical order inside a sandbox platform such as a paper-money simulator. Record the order type, limit price, and quantity exactly as the plan specified — every value labeled SIMULATED.
Compare the written plan with the displayed outcome. Document deviations, the simulator's fill model, and the interpretation limits — then write the next learning question.
A simulated fill is a statement about a model, not about a market. The Reviewbook records both sides of that distinction on every entry.
Working rule: treat every displayed fill as hypothetical by definition. The Review Sheet labels each record SIMULATED and keeps a dedicated field for what the model could not show.
Follow a single educational order from idea to review note. A study participant writes a hypothetical limit order for the fictional instrument DEMO-01 — a synthetic ticker with invented prices, volumes, and dates — then works through ten review stages to document what the simulator actually showed.
Six fields structure every entry. Together they keep a simulated record honest — each one answers a different question about the hypothetical order.
The simulation date the entry refers to, so the review can reconstruct session conditions rather than relying on memory.
The fictional or synthetic instrument used — such as DEMO-01 — labeled so no record can be mistaken for a real ticker.
The instruction itself: direction, order type, limit price, and conditional quantity, marked HYPOTHETICAL in full.
What the learner assumed about fees, spread, queue, and the platform's fill model before the order was logged.
What the simulator displayed — filled, partial, expired, or cancelled — recorded verbatim with its model label.
The explicit boundary of the entry: what the simulation could not measure and what the record must not claim.
Our independent review examines the educational simulation capabilities of the thinkorswim paperMoney sandbox — its order logging tools, replay functions, and where its fill model departs from live-market mechanics. The assessment is editorial and non-commercial: we evaluate how well the platform supports honest hypothetical recordkeeping.
Virtual trading results are learning material — a way to study process, mechanics, and discipline. They are not, and cannot be presented as, evidence of how the same decisions would perform on a live market.
No simulated record is aggregated into a performance figure or presented as a track record.
The archive provides no brokerage services, trade recommendations, copy trading, or managed strategies.
Every order example on this site is marked SIMULATED or HYPOTHETICAL and uses synthetic instruments only.
Core idea: even when a virtual order fills exactly as planned, that outcome documents the fill model — not a repeatable market result. What transfers to real study is the quality of the record, not the number it happened to display.