
Two Different Promises
A market order promises execution and accepts whatever price is available. A limit order promises a maximum (or minimum) price and accepts the risk of no execution at all. This trade-off — certainty of fill versus certainty of price — is the core lesson order types exist to teach.
Inside a simulator, both promises are only modeled. But the shape of the lesson survives the model: you can still experience what it feels like to wait for a limit that never fills, or to accept a market fill at a price you did not choose.
How Simulators Fill Market Orders
Most educational platforms fill a simulated market order at the last displayed quote, instantly and in full. This is the most generous possible model: no slippage, no partial fills, no latency. Record the fill price alongside the quote you saw when deciding; the gap between them is the first thing a live market would have charged you.
How Simulators Fill Limit Orders
Simulated limit orders usually fill the first time the displayed price touches your limit. That rule ignores queue priority and available size, so a limit fill in a journal should always carry the annotation 'touch-fill model' or the platform's documented equivalent.
The un-filled limit order is equally instructive. A limit set just outside the day's simulated range produces a clean, honest 'no fill' — an outcome worth journaling because it teaches opportunity cost, the price of patience.
- Market order: modeled certainty of fill, no certainty of price.
- Limit order: modeled certainty of price, no certainty of fill.
- Both: modeled outcomes inside a synthetic book, not a live queue.
Choosing a Type for the Record
Pick the order type by the lesson, not the preference. If the study goal is experiencing price control, the limit order is the assignment. If the goal is documenting how decisions feel under immediate execution, the market order is. Write the chosen type into the review sheet with one clause explaining why it was selected.
A disciplined journal often runs both types against the same scenario on different days, then compares the two records — same idea, different mechanics, different lessons.
Order Types Inside the Simulator vs. the Market
| Order Type | Simulator Treatment | Real-Market Behavior | Journal Caution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market | Fills at current model price | Walks the book; price depends on depth | Tag assumed slippage per entry |
| Limit | Fills when model price is touched | May never fill; queue decides | Note queue position unknown |
| Stop | Triggers at touch, fills at next print | Can slip far past the trigger in gaps | Record trigger vs. fill as two prices |
| Stop-limit | Often modeled as clean conversion | Frequently abandoned mid-move in reality | Flag unfilled legs separately |
Journal Checklist
- Is the order type recorded with its full parameter set (price, expiry, condition)?
- Is the fill model for that type noted (touch-fill, queue, partial)?
- Are trigger price and fill price logged as separate fields for stops?
- Are unfilled orders logged with a reason field, not just deleted?
- Does the entry avoid treating 'simulator fill' as proof the order type 'worked'?
Review Note
In the Review Sheet, 'Order type' is never just a dropdown value. It is a documented choice with a reason attached.
Frequently Asked Questions
Because the model guarantees a fill — real market orders buy depth, not a price. The journal should record the assumed spread and depth, not just 'filled'.
It shows the price was touched by the model — not that a real order would have been reached. Log it as a touch event with a queue caveat.
Neither — practice both, and journal the assumption set each implies. The lesson is the difference in mechanics, not a preference.
Continue Exploring
Bid-Ask Spread in a Paper Journal
How to account for the gap between bid and ask quotes when logging simulated orders, even when the simulator hides it.
Trade Notes Beyond Profit and Loss
Why educational journals should grade the quality of the decision process first, and simulated profit last.
How to Log a Cancelled Simulated Order
Cancelled orders are decisions too. How to record them so the journal captures discipline — and hesitation — accurately.