
Scenario Overview
This study tracks a synthetic large-cap basket against a synthetic small-cap basket across a scripted divergence regime, using the gap between them to teach tracking-error documentation and liquidity-friction accounting.
Divergence is a gift to journaling: two instruments, one macro story, visibly different paths. The participant's task is to document the differential as a data series — not to explain it, because in a sandbox the 'explanation' is a script parameter.
All basket compositions, weights, and spread assumptions are synthetic. Real index names appear only in the page title as genre shorthand.
Tracking Setup
| Element | Large-Cap Sleeve | Small-Cap Sleeve |
|---|---|---|
| Hypothetical instruments | 5 synthetic mega-cap tickers | 5 synthetic small-cap tickers |
| Assumed spread | 0.02% per leg | 0.35% per leg — the friction under study |
| Assumed depth | Deep; fills at touch | Thin; one-session fill delays modeled |
| Rebalance rule | Written weekly rule, same for both | Same rule — isolates instrument differences |
| Tracked metric | Differential vs. large sleeve, per session | The study's dependent variable |
Simulated Observations
- The scripted divergence regime produced the expected differential — the log treats the outcome as a fixture and spends its analysis entirely on the tracking process.
- Modeled fill delays on the small-cap sleeve changed rebalance timing enough to shift weekly tracking numbers by more than the price path did — friction, not direction, drove most of the documented error.
- The participant initially logged divergence as 'small caps underperformed' — a headline sentence. Review rewrote it into four checkable components: price path, spread cost, fill delay, and rule drift.
- One rebalance was skipped during a delayed-fill window; the journal marks it 'omitted by liquidity' rather than 'skipped by choice' — a distinction live traders routinely blur.
Friction as a First-Class Variable
The study's central argument is that in any comparison exercise, execution assumptions deserve the same field space as prices. Spread, depth, and delay are journaled as parameters of the comparison — otherwise 'which basket did better' quietly becomes 'which basket was cheaper to simulate.'
This is the Reviewbook habit applied to relative-value thinking: decompose the differential until every component is either a documented parameter or a documented unknown.
The exercise also demonstrates why sandbox comparisons must publish their friction assumptions — two simulations of 'the same divergence' with different spread models produce different answers, and only the journal reveals why.
Methodology and Limits
Real small-cap divergence involves credit sensitivity, index composition drift, earnings mix, and regime-dependent liquidity the sandbox cannot represent. The friction model here is a single configurable spread number — generous by any real standard.
The study therefore claims nothing about real cap-size dynamics. Its deliverable is a tracking discipline that would survive contact with real data, and a journal format that keeps friction honest.
Review Checklist
- Are spread, depth, and delay assumptions written as fields, not assumed away?
- Is the divergence decomposed into price path, cost, delay, and rule adherence?
- Are skipped or delayed actions labeled by cause (liquidity vs. choice)?
- Does the entry refrain from explaining real-world small-cap behavior?
Review Takeaways
The participant leaves this scenario with a differential decomposed, not a narrative about small caps. That decomposition — four honest components instead of one confident sentence — is the portable skill.
Filed in the journal, the entry anchors the site's broader lesson: comparisons are only as honest as the friction assumptions written underneath them.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. Both baskets, the divergence regime, and the friction model are synthetic parameters. The study measures the participant's tracking discipline, not market dynamics.
Decomposing a differential into checkable components — price path, spread cost, fill delay, rule adherence — instead of writing 'small caps underperformed,' which is a headline, not a record.
Because 'which basket did better' silently becomes 'which basket was cheaper to simulate' unless execution assumptions get the same field space as prices. Omitted friction is invisible bias.
A skipped action labeled by cause: the delayed fill window made the rebalance impossible. Distinguishing 'couldn't' from 'chose not to' is a distinction live journals routinely blur.
Review Note
Divergence in a model measures your tracking discipline — the gap between the baskets matters less than the gap between plan and entry.
Continue Exploring
Janus Henderson Markets Overview
A comprehensive appraisal of sovereign debt benchmarks, corporate credit spreads, and cross-asset correlation models.
US GDPNow Data Simulation
Simulated real-time tracking of Atlanta Fed growth estimates and sectoral sensitivity analysis across synthetic portfolio configurations.
Massive Tech Sell-Off Simulation
Stress-testing simulated portfolio resilience across multiple software and semiconductor allocations during severe sector-wide volatility expansion.